Inside Jobs, June 27, 2008

Find Your Torch Points

Without a doubt, Customer Relationship Management – or CRM – has become a mainstay in current day business vernacular. Business professionals now talk effortlessly about touch points, customer experience, customer segmentation, and cross-channel integration. CRM has come a long way since its early days, but there’s still a lot of room for improvement.

Despite the maturing of this once nascent business capability, companies continue to struggle to consistently deliver seamless, effective, and meaningful customer interactions. It’s no wonder that customer satisfaction can be elusive for so many companies.

Although most companies will proudly tout their CRM capabilities, the true measure of success is customer satisfaction. The stakes are indeed high; in a competitive market, the ability to build and nurture customer satisfaction can make the difference between success and failure.

Too often, however, even the best of CRM intentions can miss the mark; promotions can miss the mark, cross-channel experiences can be inconsistent, and call center navigation can be inconvenient. When issues arise, they create a torch point; a defect in the CRM process that can leave the customer wanting or frustrated. The severity of each torch point can diminish customer satisfaction or lead to outright defection.

Finding the torch points in your business requires an unrelenting focus on quality, a heavy dose of process discipline, and an industrial strength measurement capability.

Consider the automotive industry; manufacturers were taught a costly lesson that defects and lower quality led to rapid erosion of customer satisfaction, brand perception, revenues, and profits. Automotive manufacturers responded by developing an unrelenting focus on quality; they managed process quality, measured every minute detail, and developed robust product testing capabilities.

In our automobile example, defects are easy to spot; when the car won’t start, the transmission fails, or the air conditioning goes out – it’s pretty obvious that there is a problem. In the CRM world, however, the torch points aren’t so readily evident. Businesses have to look closer to see where their customer relationship capabilities might be breaking down.

CRM torch points can occur in a variety of situations or interactions. Here are just a few examples that seem to occur too often in today’s business environment:

1. Account number fumble: When a customer contacts a call center they are asked to enter their multi-digit account number. Yet when they get transferred to a live customer service agent, they are asked for this information again.
2. Promotion defect: A consumer products manufacturer or retailer runs a promotion on Father’s Day weekend for 20% off a particular item. Some customers snap up the deal but forget to bring their coupon or specific promotion code. If and when the customer returns with the coupon to collect the 20% discount, the store won’t honor it since it is now past the promotion period, even if the customer has the receipt to prove the date of purchase.
3. Sorry, wrong channel: A customer visits a web site only to find that they can’t find the product they were looking for unless they visit the store. Conversely, they visit the retail store only to find out that they are out of stock and are directed to the web site to see if it’s available online.
4. No card, no benefit: Many businesses utilize the ever-popular loyalty card to dispense rewards or discounts. An extremely loyal customer drops into their preferred store without their loyalty card. Despite being an extremely loyal customer, the store refuses to dispense any rewards or discounts without the physical loyalty card.
5. Feel the pressure: Cross-selling and up-selling can be lucrative for many businesses, but applying pressure sales to get customers to buy more can often have a negative impact on the customer experience. A customer that is ready to complete their shopping experience is confronted with a pressure sales environment trying to get them to ‘buy more.’

These are just a few simple examples of torch points that can occur anywhere in the customer experience lifecycle. Even the best of CRM intentions can sometimes miss the mark; promotion policies can create buyer’s remorse, cross-channel experiences can be inconsistent, and call center navigation can be inconvenient. When CRM torch points arise they can leave the customer wanting, frustrated, and unsatisfied.

If your business smells CRM smoke, it might be time to put out the torch point fires.

Do you know where your CRM torch points might be?

Inside Jobs, June 23, 2008

Got Blueprint?

Customer Experience: Fine Architecture or House of Horrors?

Imagine what would happen if you had dozens of architects and hundreds of contractors all working on your business. Now image if there was no master plan and each individual spoke his or her own unique language. It’s not hard to imagine that you would have something that would resemble the Winchester House - the now-famous 160-room house that was cobbled together over a 38-year span with no master plan. The house is notorious for stairs that go nowhere, doors that open to a 2-story drop, and a maze of rooms, hallways and doorways that can perplex even the most seasoned of navigators.

Losing site of the big picture can happen to even the best of businesses. When short-term business challenges inevitably arise, decisions can be made in haste to address them. Without a master plan, those seemingly innocent decisions can begin to create a burden for the company in the long run. Independent and uncoordinated business initiatives can result in processes that don’t connect, systems that don’t play well with others, and departments that develop their own unique business lingo that is not universally understood by others.

Like the Winchester house, each individual project may seem like the right solution at the time. However, the compound affect of numerous independent and uncoordinated projects and solutions can result in an Achilles heal for the company: True change becomes increasingly hard to accomplish; integration and sharing of key business data slows to a crawl; and enabling cross-functional processes (aka end-to-end processes) becomes nearly impossible to accomplish. Each function may seem content, but the business as a whole can begin to suffer due to inflexibility, knowledge hoarding, and turf wars.

Indicators that your business may suffer from the ‘Winchester House’ syndrome:

1. Process Indicators: Business processes are not well defined or understood and each function prides itself on simply doing whatever is necessary to ‘get the job done,’ even if it requires winging it now and then. Each functional area designs, develops, and manages its own unique processes with little or no sharing of best practices across functional areas.


2. Technology Indicators: Each functional area has its own set of business applications and data. Applications often don’t work well with others and data is not consistent across departments. Key business information is fragmented and stored in multiple locations and collecting data to conduct company-wide analysis is a long, difficult, and largely a manual process.


3. People Indicators: Individual functional areas have very specialized people, and it takes years to train new employees to ‘learn the ropes’ of the business. Employees care only about their functional area, have their own set of performance goals and metrics, and don’t understand how or why other functional areas get things done.

Unfortunately, when companies lose sight of the bigger picture and become a victim of the ‘Winchester House’ syndrome, the customer experience invariably suffers. Customers can be inconvenienced by inconsistencies between touch points, lack of integration between channels, and absence of a meaningful relationship between customer and company. The company’s internal processes, policies, and infrastructure often ‘get in the way’ of providing the customer with what they want; an emotional connection to the company powered by great service.


See the Forest Through the Trees

Businesses that want to avoid this fate can and should establish, adopt, and diligently adhere to an enterprise customer experience blueprint; a holistic model that defines how every component of the company should work together in a seamless and consistent manner to enable and optimize the customer experience. Furthermore, the enterprise blueprint can help a business to develop a detailed master plan for where the business is today and where it is going.

An enterprise blueprint can help any business to avoid the ‘Winchester House’ syndrome by serving as a detailed model for how the customer experience is influenced and enabled by the compilation of people, process, and technology assets. A comprehensive enterprise blueprint will consist of a detailed definition and model for each major component that comprise the business. This model can be invaluable for identifying any current deficiencies as well as charting a future course for the business.

A comprehensive enterprise customer experience blueprint includes several key dimensions:

1. Customer Experience Lifecycle (Customer): A formal definition of the customer experience lifecycle process from the customer’s perspective. The process includes a complete end-to-end view of how customers are attracted, acquired, facilitated, served, and cultivated well after the point of purchase.


2. Enterprise Business Process (Process): A formal and detailed enterprise process model that defines all major processes, sub-processes, and activities that comprise the enterprise. Ideally, the process model should be defined as a hierarchy to allow both low-level analysis and optimization as well as executive-level roll-up of detailed activities into larger process areas.


3. Enterprise Systems Architecture (Technology): A complete information technology model that identifies and defines key IT capabilities, applications, data, and infrastructure. Ideally, the components of the IT architecture model should be expressly linked to the customer, process, and people dimensions of the blueprint.


4. Enterprise Organization Chart (People): An enterprise-wide organization chart that includes an up-to-date definition of the reporting structure, roles, and responsibilities.


5. Enterprise Business Metrics (Value): A standardized definition of all key business metrics that includes a definition of how the metric is calculated and where key data is sourced from in the enterprise.


6. Corporate Strategy (Strategy): A clear and well-defined strategy that sets the long-term goals and directions for the company. The corporate strategy should include components to define specific strategies for areas such as the brand, market, product, service, price, promotion, channel, and customer experience.

Enterprise Blueprint – It Does Your Business Good

Businesses that are seeking clarity to their current and future business environment can develop their own enterprise customer experience blueprint by identifying and analyzing their key business assets:

1. Assemble available business artifacts: Gather all available customer experience processes, business processes, technology architectures, organization structures, business metrics, and strategies that are available for the business.


2. Identify gaps and inconsistencies: Evaluate the existing business artifacts to identify what is missing, where inconsistencies or duplications occur, or where additional detail is lacking for each of the major dimensions (customer, process, people, technology, value, and strategy).


3. Create standard definitions and assemble the blueprint: Create and agree to a common set of standards to accurately define and describe each dimension of the blueprint and close any gaps that are identified. Consolidate and summarize all artifacts into a comprehensive enterprise customer experience blueprint and keep them up to date. Use the blueprint as a management tool to guide the business going forward.

Developing and using a comprehensive blueprint has its benefits; businesses that define and maintain a comprehensive enterprise customer experience blueprint can improve their return on investments, increase productivity, and improve the customer experience:

• Improved ROI: Initiatives that are better aligned with the enterprise blueprint can result in fewer conflicts and duplication of efforts. Furthermore, short-term efforts can be better aligned with long-term goals so that all resources are rowing in the same direction.


• Increased Productivity: Business can run more smoothly and produce more for the same or less effort by leveraging common resources, speaking the same process and business metric language, and by using a common and consistent set of information. Furthermore, businesses can make better decisions based on a more holistic and consistent view of enterprise-wide capabilities, issues, risks, and opportunities.


• Improved Customer Experience: Businesses that have aligned their people, process, and technology components are better equipped to provide meaningful customer experiences. When aligned and consistent, the business infrastructure can serve as a true enabler – rather than a hindrance – to powerful customer experiences.

Executive Summary

Over the course of the lifetime of a business various business challenges, opportunities, and issues will arise and be solved by numerous and seemingly innocent business decisions; decisions that result in new processes, organizational structures, and systems. Without an overarching blueprint to guide these decisions, however, the legacy of various and uncoordinated initiatives can be crippling. As more and more independent decisions are made, the weight of inconsistent processes, duplication of duties, and incompatible systems can burden both the company and the customer.

Business that want to avoid this fate can and should establish, adopt, and diligently adhere to an enterprise customer experience blueprint; a holistic model that defines how every component of the company should work together in a seamless and consistent manner to enable and optimize the customer experience. A comprehensive enterprise customer experience blueprint includes several key dimensions including a 1) Customer Experience Lifecycle Process (Customer), 2) an Enterprise Business Process Model(Process), 3) an Enterprise Systems Architecture (Technology, 4) an Enterprise Organization Chart (People), 5) Enterprise Business Metrics (Value), and 6) a Corporate Strategy (Strategy).

If your business were a house or building, what would it look like to your employees and customers? Would it be structurally sound, open, and inviting? Or would it be cluttered, broken up and difficult to navigate?

Having the right blueprint can make all the difference.

Inside Jobs, May 30, 2008

Why Customer Experience Matters Most

Companies have long competed on manufacturing capabilities, innovation, or traditional customer service. But finding new ways to create a differentiated offering in those areas are increasingly difficult to find. As a result, customer experience has emerged as the new battleground to create long, broad and deep customer relationships; relationships which can differentiate your company and deliver significant value to the bottom line.

Strategically, a unique customer experience can differentiate your company in the marketplace. In a marketplace where competitive parity and/or commoditization have set in, customer experience becomes one of the few alternatives for strategic differentiation. Perhaps an over-cited example is Starbuck’s, where they have converted coffee from a commodity into a destination site that plays to customer’s emotions, tastes, and a feeling of prestige – mostly based on a unique customer experience (and some pretty good coffee, too.)

Optimizing the customer experience may sound like another noble cause, but the results can be real. Let’s take a simple example of two truck stops along a major interstate highway that both sell gasoline at the same price. The first station is clean, well lit, and has a pay-at-the-pump features. The second station has paint chipping, a broken sign, and requires that you pre-pay for gasoline. It’s pretty easy to guess that while the second station may have an occasional customer wander in, the first station has more repeat customers and customers who are willing to buy other products and services. Simply put, that means more revenue (more customers for longer) and higher profits (selling more products and services to the same customer for the same attraction costs).

Achieving real results from an improved customer experience is as straight forward as a-b-c. The revenue that you realize from each customer is determined by a) depth, b) breadth, and c) duration of your relationship. Improve upon any of these key factors and you can realize significant results.

The depth of your customer experience is the level of commitment, loyalty, and meaningfulness of your customer relationships. Customer relationship depth can be measured in several ways, but perhaps the most obvious is the frequency of customer visits or transactions. For example, a customer may get his hardware supplies at a local hardware store for smaller items, but shop the big-box hardware store for larger items. Increasing the depth of the relationship means converting those transactions from the other store to yours by delivering a substantially better customer experience.

The breadth of your customer experience is the number of reasons that your customers transact with your company. Customer breadth can be measured by the total portfolio of products or services purchased by each individual customer. For example, the big box retailers such as Wal-Mart, Target, and K-mart have all added product lines, such as groceries, to expand the breadth of their relationship with their customers. Their intent: To be the one-stop shop for everything.

The duration of your customer experience is the total time, from first recognition to final defection, that your customer has a relationship with your company. Customer duration can be measured by the total time that a customer has interacted with your company. The value of increasing customer duration is clear; serving your existing customers is almost always more profitable than attracting new ones. In one example during my consulting career, we spent nearly as much on getting the sale than the total sale was worth. Obviously, expensive customer attraction activities are not profitable for your company. Keep the customers you have.

During the initial incubation stages of your project, you shouldn’t expect to have a complete, detailed and final business case. We address that activity in depth in the following chapter. However, establishing the intent of your project based on the potential value gains can help to formulate the vision, goals, and objectives for the project and properly align your executive sponsors’ expectations and support.

We focus on the value associated with improved customer experiences because it matters. It matters to your customers that make a conscious decision every time they choose to spend their dollars. It matters to your company as you seek to increase revenues and profit margin. And it matters to your stakeholders to know that your company has an unbeatable competitive advantage in the marketplace.

Focus on the value of the customer experience – because it matters more than anything.

Inside Jobs, May 22, 2008